How should comment notifications work?
Explanation:
Seeing polls are quite popular recently, I would like to create one too:
At the moment when a user engages in a thread (say by commenting or following it), they are included in the notification list until they un-follow. As per very old logic, they are notified about all the comments, inc. any replies to any comments - as one can expect this might be too much.
Just to be 100% clear - the answers relate only to the case when user is following the thread.
You need to log in to be able to vote and see the results.
This comment was deleted by its author.
3 months ago@Ca... didn't quite follow them. Disorder and entropy is a function of time though ;)
@Ca... but more seriously, getting the right amount of notification could be a way to at least ..
@To... I'll get round to voting when I've boned up on thermodynamics a bit.
@To... it says as per normal, notified about All comments and replies but as i have said before I do..
@Bo... I think what you're describing it's something else though: you most probably get all the noti..
@To... No not really, just got 1 new notification and went to thread but there were 2 replies on the..
@Bo... ok let's wait till tomorrow, otherwise please remind me or SL support.
@To... - I found it useful, the other day, to consider a comment with replies as a separate thread, ..
It's all getting too complicated for me. I'd like less notifications. For example, I'd just like num..
@Da... - you'd like a "mentions and replies only" setting, correct? (Conceptually, that works for me..
But then again, would 'replies' mean direct replies only, or 'replies to replies to replies...' down..
Where`s the `couldn`t give a monkeys` option?🤣
@Pe... direct replies, then when you go read it you would naturally see the subthread
@Da... - but what about after that? Replies to that reply might (hopefully!) be related to your own ..
@Pe... yes, I rarely find sub thread replies anything to do with my post lol
Where's the "It's all got far too complicated for me" option? 🤣
Or the "It was working fine for me before all these changes" option? 🤣
or the "only mark each recommendation as read and not those in the whole post"
The only issue is in relation to deleted or removed posts
@To... A bit of feedback about the new layout of replies grouped to a comment.
After the initial te..
@Mr... ok thanks, there are still a few adjustments in the pipeline in regards to that, we'll ..
@li... - that's a separate issue. If a post or comment is deleted, it would be less frustrating if ..
@li... I'm not 100% sure, but I reckon this has been done already - if a post gets removed, related..
@To... - I must admit I don't remember a notification taking me to a non-existent comment, certainly..
@To... I still think it would be handy to be able to just open the replies on each subthread separat..
@Da... yes, it's a bit complicated to make it all work nicely with notifications too, but it's on th..
@To... Thank you for making my long overdue badge one of your "pressing issues". Was beginning to th..
@Un... - bless, now you can play with the big kids!
@Se... That's another one off the bucket list then😉
@Un... Well done about time you got one.
@Bo... please see if you still have that problem (for any new notifications from now on).
@Ma... Thank you, Mary. You definitely have a heart of solid gold💛
What's happening with comments? It used to be that if there were, say, 6 comments in a thread I c..
They're not clearing at all now even though I've read the comment replied.
@An... yes it’s a bit frustrating but I am hoping it’s just another one of those temporary glitches d..
@An... please see my post from yesterday https://www.scooploop.com/thread/couple-of-fixes-and-changes..
@To... Thank you.
Lightbulb? What lightbulb? I think I'm getting too old for this malarky 😅
Well this one isn`t clearing for me but all the others seem to have-very odd???
Ha,ha-as soon as I posted this-they allc leared-s*d`s law!! 🤣
@An... the one that shows just under the comment made by the original poster on the right hand side
Mine aren't
@Bo... mine haven’t either but it’s not a problem click on the ones you want and then ‘read all’ 🤙🏽
@Ro... I haven't got a read all option
@Bo... sorry it’s at the top it says ‘Mark all as read’
@Bo...
@Ro... yes but i only want to mark all as read from the one thread, not all of them on the list
@Bo... 🤔
@Ro... It must have gone out because I can't see it
@An... I thought these new light bulbs were supposed to last longer.
@Bo... Mine are definitely a bit inconsistent. Certainly other notifications in this thread aren`t `..
Sometimes things take a few seconds/a minute to `catch-up` So that it can be showing the notificatio..
I am giving up lol